Elf O'Clock Make your elf Elf emergency?

76 Christmas would you rather questions for kids

Here are 76 Christmas would you rather questions for kids, all new and all kind: 16 silly ones for ages 3 to 6, 18 funny ones for 7 to 10, 16 think-about-it ones for 11 and up (grown-ups too), 14 for round the table at Christmas dinner and 12 for a car journey. Ask one, let everyone pick a side, then ask "why?". There are no wrong answers, which makes them a gentle way to get even a quiet child talking.

Want a punchline instead? Try 50 Christmas jokes for kids. Want something to work out? Try 50 Christmas riddles.

Silly Christmas would you rather questions (ages 3 to 6)

Short, with two things little ones can picture. If they can't choose, ask them to draw both, or point to one of two hands as you say each answer.

  1. Would you rather be a snowman or a gingerbread person?
  2. Would you rather ride a reindeer or a polar bear?
  3. Would you rather live in a house made of gingerbread or a house made of snow?
  4. Would you rather have a pet penguin or a pet reindeer?
  5. Would you rather wear a jumper (sweater) with flashing lights or a jumper (sweater) that plays Jingle Bells?
  6. Would you rather be as small as a bauble or as tall as the Christmas tree?
  7. Would you rather have a sledge (sled) pulled by dogs or a sledge pulled by ducks?
  8. Would you rather bounce on a giant marshmallow or slide down a giant candy cane?
  9. Would you rather sleep in a huge stocking or sleep in a huge present box?
  10. Would you rather have snow that tastes of ice cream or rain that tastes of hot chocolate?
  11. Would you rather be a robin or a penguin?
  12. Would you rather build one snowman as big as a house or a hundred tiny snowmen?
  13. Would you rather wear a crown made of tinsel or a hat made of a paper plate?
  14. Would you rather have a Christmas tree in your bedroom or a snowman in the garden that waves at you?
  15. Would you rather be the star on top of the tree or a present underneath it?
  16. Would you rather hop like a reindeer or waddle like a penguin all the way to breakfast?

Funny Christmas would you rather questions (ages 7 to 10)

Sillier choices with a bit more to imagine. These work best when everyone has to give a reason.

  1. Would you rather sing everything you say like a carol, or say everything in rhyme, for the whole of Christmas Day?
  2. Would you rather have a Christmas tree that sneezes glitter or a snowman that tells terrible jokes?
  3. Would you rather wrap every present with one hand or with your eyes shut?
  4. Would you rather pull a cracker that bangs as loud as a firework or one that only whispers "pop"?
  5. Would you rather wear your paper crown for all of December or your Christmas jumper for all of December?
  6. Would you rather have a penguin as your teacher or a reindeer as your football coach?
  7. Would you rather freeze anything you point at for ten seconds or make it snow indoors whenever you clap?
  8. Would you rather have a snowball fight with a snowman who throws back or race a penguin on sledges?
  9. Would you rather unwrap a present that gets bigger with every layer or one that gets smaller and smaller?
  10. Would you rather spend Christmas Day on the Moon or at the bottom of the sea?
  11. Would you rather have a talking tree that only tells knock-knock jokes or a talking fridge that only sings carols?
  12. Would you rather build a gingerbread house big enough to live in or a gingerbread person who comes to life and runs off?
  13. Would you rather have a snow day every Monday in December or a pyjama day every Friday?
  14. Would you rather open your presents in slow motion or at super speed?
  15. Would you rather be a cat at Christmas (so many boxes to sit in) or a dog at Christmas (so much wrapping paper to chase)?
  16. Would you rather be in charge of the crackers or in charge of the music on Christmas Day?
  17. Would you rather invent a brand new Christmas sweet or a brand new Christmas song?
  18. Would you rather have every Christmas song stuck in your head at once or have one song stuck there all month?

Think-about-it questions (11 and up and grown-ups)

These have no easy answer, so they start real conversations. Grown-ups answer too: children love hearing what their grown-ups would pick and why.

  1. Would you rather have Christmas once every two years and make it twice as big, or have it twice a year and keep it the same size?
  2. Would you rather know exactly what every present is before you open it, or never find out who any of them came from?
  3. Would you rather have snow every Christmas or spend every Christmas somewhere sunny?
  4. Would you rather give one present you made yourself or ten you picked from a shop?
  5. Would you rather live your best Christmas Day again exactly as it was, or have a brand new one you can't predict?
  6. Would you rather be able to pause time on Christmas morning or replay Christmas Eve once?
  7. Would you rather keep every Christmas tradition exactly the same forever or start one new one every year?
  8. Would you rather spend Christmas in a cabin with no screens or in a city covered in lights?
  9. Would you rather write a letter to yourself to open next Christmas, or read one you wrote five years ago?
  10. Would you rather be the one who cooks Christmas dinner or the one who washes up afterwards?
  11. Would you rather have someone choose the perfect present for you, or always choose the perfect present for everyone else?
  12. Would you rather hear Christmas music from 1 November or not hear a single carol until Christmas Eve?
  13. Would you rather get one big present or lots of small surprises spread across December?
  14. Would you rather have the best Christmas lights in your street or make the best mince pies anyone has tasted?
  15. Would you rather have a big, busy Christmas with lots of people or a small, quiet one?
  16. Would you rather travel back to see Christmas a hundred years ago or forward to see it a hundred years from now?

Would you rather questions for round the table at Christmas dinner

Ask one between courses, or pop them on slips of paper beside each plate. In the US, where crackers are less common, swap the cracker questions for party hats or anything on your table.

  1. Would you rather have pigs in blankets (little sausages wrapped in bacon) with every meal or roast potatoes with every meal?
  2. Would you rather eat your pudding first or save it for the very end?
  3. Would you rather tell the cracker jokes in a pirate voice or a very posh voice?
  4. Would you rather get the crispiest roast potato or the last mince pie?
  5. Would you rather have Christmas dinner in a treehouse or on a boat?
  6. Would you rather find a tiny toy in your cracker or a really good joke?
  7. Would you rather have Christmas dinner for breakfast or breakfast for Christmas dinner?
  8. Would you rather make a one-sentence toast or start a song everyone joins in with?
  9. Would you rather pass every dish round with a dance move or give every dish a silly new name?
  10. Would you rather keep your cracker hat on until bedtime or swap hats with the person next to you after every course?
  11. Would you rather remember everyone's favourite food or everyone's favourite Christmas memory?
  12. Would you rather have a table as long as a street with everyone you like, or a tiny table for two in a snowy forest?
  13. Would you rather be in charge of laying the table or in charge of decorating it?
  14. Would you rather have a dessert that sparkles or a dessert that's on fire (with a grown-up holding the match)?

Would you rather questions for a Christmas car journey

Good for the drive to see family, the trip to look at lights or any long journey. The driver joins in by talking only: no thumbs or hands off the wheel, and children stay buckled in.

  1. Would you rather count every red car or every Christmas tree in a window?
  2. Would you rather have a car that flies over the traffic or a car that turns into a sleigh?
  3. Would you rather sing every carol you know or play I spy the whole way?
  4. Would you rather have a horn that plays Jingle Bells or indicators that twinkle like fairy lights?
  5. Would you rather have a reindeer driving or a penguin reading the map?
  6. Would you rather travel by sledge, by steam train or by hot-air balloon?
  7. Would you rather drive past a house covered in a million lights or a field with real reindeer in it?
  8. Would you rather choose all the music for the trip or choose where you stop for a break?
  9. Would you rather be the first to spot a snowflake or the first to spot a house with lights?
  10. Would you rather listen to a story the whole way or make one up together, one sentence each?
  11. Would you rather have a car roof that opens to show the stars or windows that show snow falling outside?
  12. Would you rather be able to blink and be home, or have a magic window that shows snowy mountains the whole way?

How do you play Christmas would you rather?

  1. Stand on a side. Point to one side of the room for each answer and everyone walks to their choice. Clear the floor first, and keep it walking, not running, with little ones about.
  2. Thumbs up or down. Say the first answer: thumbs up if you'd pick it, thumbs down if you'd pick the other. Good at the table or on the sofa.
  3. The "why?" rule. Everyone who answers gives one reason. Any reason counts, even "because penguins are funny".
  4. Change your mind. After the reasons, anyone can swap sides. It's fun to see who talked people round.
  5. Guess the room. Before asking, the person reading guesses which answer most people will pick. A point if they're right.
  6. Make your own. Each person writes one question on a slip of paper and drops it in a bowl. Pull one out at a time.

How do you make up your own Christmas would you rather questions?

  • Use the pattern "Would you rather [something fun] or [something else fun]?" Both answers should be things someone would happily pick.
  • Mix one ordinary Christmas thing with one impossible one: a snowman, but it can talk; a sledge, but ducks pull it.
  • Keep it kind: no questions about people in the room, how anyone looks, money or anyone's family, and nothing that would put someone off their dinner.
  • For little ones, keep both answers to one thing they can picture. For older children, add a twist that makes it hard to choose.

How can would you rather questions help a quiet child talk?

Would you rather works for a shy or quiet child because there is no wrong answer and nothing personal to say. A choice is easier than an open question like "what was the best bit of your day?"

  • Go first yourself, with a silly reason. It shows there's no right answer and takes the spotlight off them.
  • Ask side by side, not face to face: in the car, while washing up, on a walk or while making something.
  • Let pointing, nodding or thumbs count as an answer. Talking can come later.
  • Always allow "pass". A child who knows they can pass is more likely to join in.
  • Follow up with a small, easy question about their answer: "What would you do first?" or "What would you call your penguin?"
  • Ask one at a time in a crowd, or save them for later if a big family day is a lot. A quiet space and a break card can help on busy days.

For more to do together, see Christmas party games for the whole room, and the jokes and riddles for the gaps in between.

What is a good Christmas would you rather question for kids?

One where both answers sound fun, like "Would you rather ride a reindeer or a polar bear?" or "Would you rather spend Christmas Day on the Moon or at the bottom of the sea?" The fun is in picking a side and saying why.

How do you play would you rather at Christmas?

Read a question out and everyone picks an answer, by standing on one side of the room, doing thumbs up or down, or just saying it. Then each person gives one reason, and anyone can change their mind.

What age is would you rather good for?

Every age. Children of 3 to 6 like simple choices they can picture, 7 to 10s like silly impossible ones, and 11s, teenagers and grown-ups enjoy the harder questions that start a proper conversation.

Are would you rather questions good conversation starters for kids?

Yes. A choice with no wrong answer is easier than an open question, so quiet children often join in. Answer first yourself, ask side by side, and let them pass if they want to.

More guides

Elf Letters and more

A few emails a week until Christmas, with ideas, tips, printables and news, and one the day the app is out. Then the odd one through the year.

See everything you get

You get all 20 printables, plus the arrival letter and a bonus puzzle pack, as soon as you confirm:

  • The Elf is tired notes printableElf is tired notes
  • The Treasure hunt clue cards printableTreasure hunt clue cards
  • The Password card printablePassword card
  • The Elf at work warning tape printableElf at work warning tape
  • The Elf passport printableElf passport
  • The Snowball fight scorecard printableSnowball fight scorecard
  • The Sticker chart printableSticker chart
  • The The elf's December diary printableThe elf's December diary
  • The Joke cards from the elves printableJoke cards from the elves
  • The Christmas Eve box tags printableChristmas Eve box tags
  • The Santa's reply paper printableSanta's reply paper
  • The Elf at work door sign printableElf at work door sign
  • The Tiny elf menu printableTiny elf menu
  • The The elf's shopping list printableThe elf's shopping list
  • The Bauble template printableBauble template
  • The Paper chain strips printablePaper chain strips
  • The Christmas bingo printableChristmas bingo
  • The Colour by number printableColour by number
  • The Dot to dot printableDot to dot
  • The The Elfish key printableThe Elfish key

For parents and carers, 18+. The emails come from Elf O'Clock (hello@elfoclock.com); we'll email you to confirm, and you can unsubscribe any time with one click. See our privacy policy.